National Insurance - A Tax on Jobs?

HMRC taxation systemsAt last there is clear blue water between the UK political parties in the run up to the General Election - over taxation.
And the parties are acting true to traditional form - Labour wants to raise taxes, and Conservatives want to lower them.
But the picture isn't quite so straightforward.  The Tax selected, National Insurance, is actually a tax on the poor, taxing those on low and middle income at a higher rate than those on high income.
National Insurance is a sort-of 'hidden' tax.  It doesn't appear on any headline rate, so successive governments, in my memory beginning with Margaret Thatcher (Conservative) but probably since a long time before, have kept income tax low whilst taking the money out of yours and my pay packets through National Insurance.  It has now reached a phenomenal 23.8% (higher than the average tax rate which is made up of 20%, 40% and 50% tax rates with a tax-free allowance for the lowest paid).  The trick is, that over half of NI is paid directly by the employer to the treasury and doesn't appear on my pay slip, so although it is part of my cost of employment, I don't see enough to get upset.  I do see the 11% I pay, just not the 12.8% my employer pays.
Labour plans to raise National Insurance still further, though I'm not clear whether this is by 2% overall (1% on Employers and 1% on Employees) or only 1%. Either way, it is enormous.  But it is much worse than this - National Insurance represents a tax on the poor because above a certain income (£844/week ~ £42,000/year) the employee rate goes down to 1%.  This means that the total tax take from payroll (ie Income tax, National Insurance by employee, National Insurance by Employer) is:

Earnings/year
% Income Tax
% NI
Total Tax
Earnings in Euro
Earnings in USD

 £             4,696.00
0%
0%
0%
€ 5,307.12
$7,147.62

 £          12,000.00
9%
13%
23%
€ 13,561.64
$18,264.78

 £          18,000.00
13%
17%
30%
€ 20,342.45
$27,397.18

 £          24,500.00
15%
19%
33%
€ 27,688.34
$37,290.60

 £          50,000.00
22%
20%
43%
€ 56,506.82
$76,103.27

 £          75,000.00
28%
18%
46%
€ 84,760.22
$114,154.90

 £        120,000.00
34%
16%
50%
€ 135,616.36
$182,647.85

 £        200,000.00
39%
15%
54%
€ 226,027.27
$304,413.08 

 
National Insurance actually starts to go DOWN as a % of the total after £50,000 earnings per year, and total taxation hardly rises as a % above this level.

Can we have a little more honesty from politicians please?

Comments

Recent Additions and Updates

A moral dimension to consulting

Moral dilemmaIt's easy to assume that all of our decisions are purely rational, but they rarely if ever are rational.  And they always have consequences for others, usually consequences that we think we could not have predicted.

But consultants are not here to make decisions, only to provide information and advice.  Does this somehow absolve us from a moral responsibility?

 

The Ten Commandments in Professional Services (6-10)

Interpreting God's Commandments

I've written previously about applying the first five commandments to Professional Services.  Here I show how Do Not Murder, Do Not Steal and so on are just as relevant commandments in the nuance and subtlety of modern life as they ever were.

Read on - and there's an invitation to comment!

The 10 Commandments in Professional Services (1-5)

Keywords:

Two greatest commandsThe Ten Commandments apply just as firmly in each aspect of our daily life as they apply to the whole of our lives.  I'm a management consultant, and on this page I explain how the first five of the Ten Commandments apply to management consulting and professional services.

Getting GPs involved in Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCG)

Life in the YearsMost healthcare providers, in UK the same as everywhere else, get paid for each activity they do.  If someone needs care, they get paid.  If someone is well, they don’t.  So there isn’t much incentive (for the healthcare provider) to keep people well, even though it is much better for the person, much better for the nation, and much lower cost.  Minney.org Ltd is working with one CCG to generate enthusiasm and involvement, and the results are fairly successful….

Clinical Commissioning Groups and the NHS

Commissioning Innovation

As we race forwards into clinical commissioning, there are lessons to be learnt from other people.  The latest book “The Innovator’s Prescription: A Disruptive Solution for Health Care” by Christensen, Grossman and Hwang points to some things we need to take account of. It makes good reading . . .